Before the years end putnam had become a practicing jew, turned his mind and research to more ethical issues, and begun to engage jewish philosophy. Im sure most of you have already encountered this article at some point in an undergrad program, but incase anyone hasnt, i think this is an excellent piece. The meaning of meaning hilary putnams classic twin earth. The twin earth thought experiment was one of three, the other two being the aluminummolybdenum, and the. Explanation and reference i i explanation and reference i. Unfortunately in the pdf pages 218 and 219 are missing. The time has come to reform philosophy, says hilary putnam, one of americas great philosophers. Reason, truth and history ebook written by hilary putnam. Marieluise raters and marcus willaschek frankfurt am main.
Putnam s parents lived in france until 1934, and then in philadelphia, where he graduated from the university of pennsylvania. Minnesota studies in the philosophy of science, volume 7 1975, page 1193. The meaning of meaning putnams article meaning and reference 1973 was subsequently expanded into a much longer paper called the meaning of meaning 1975. Quine, donald davidson, john mcdowell, michael dummett, hilary putnam, saul kripke, david wiggins, and gareth evans.
Responding to hilary putnam s meaning and reference the meaning of meaning. His views on meaning, first laid out in meaning and reference 1973, then in the meaning. I shall argue that these two assumptions are not jointly satisfied by any notion, let alone any notion of. Hilary putnam was awarded the rolf schock prize in logic and philosophy by the royal swedish academy of sciences in 2011 for his contribution to the understanding of semantics for theoretical. Twin earth is a thought experiment by philosopher hilary putnam, first in his paper meaning and reference, and then in his paper the meaning of meaning, to illustrate his argument for semantic externalism, or the view that the meanings of words are ultimately not purely psychological. He made significant contributions to philosophy of mind, philosophy of language, philosophy of mathematics, and philosophy of science.
The meaning of meaning hilary putnams classic twin earth argument for semantic externalism. Hilary putnam on meaning and necessity diva portal. He calls upon philosophers to attend to the gap between the present condition of their subject and the human aspirations that philosophy should and once did claim to represent. Frege of course also held that sense determines reference, or that intension determines extension. Hilary whitehall putnam was an american philosopher, mathematician, and computer scientist. Putnam quickly came to find existential comfort and meaning in the rituals of judaism, especially communal prayer. The longer paper contains a number of things that help to make clear what he is getting at in the shorter version. Putnam also concludes that the meaning of words often involves a great deal of division of linguistic labor. Introduction in the first chapter of reason, truth and history,1 putnam argued that it is not epistemically possible that we are brains in a vat of a certain sort. Thus, putnam claims, traditional views about meaning are committed to two claims.
While hilary putnam s work on theories of meaning, semantic content, the nature of mental phenomena, interpretations of quantum mechanics, theorychange, logic, and mathematics is crucial to recent and future developments in philosophy, the scope and volume of his writings and his radical rethinking of concepts make it challenging to portray his philosophy accurately. Meaning and reference hilary putnam the journal of. Billie eilish guesses how 4,669 fans responded to a survey about her teen vogue duration. Meaning and reference hilary putnam the journal of philosophy. Beginning in the mid1970s, putnam sought to distinguish his understanding of realism from what he now called metaphysical realism. Brains in a vat, subjectivity, and the causal theory of reference kirk ludwig department of philosophy university of florida gainesville, fl 326118545 1. July 31, 1926 march, 2016 was an american philosopher, mathematician, and computer scientist, and a major figure in analytic philosophy in the second half of the 20th century. In this dissertation on hilary putnam s philosophy, i investigate his development regarding meaning and necessity, in particular mathematical necessity. The volume contains his major essays from 1975 to 1982, which reveal a large shift in emphasis in the realist position developed in his earlier work. Hilary putnam, born july 31, 1926, chicago, illinois, u. Meaning and the moral sciences hilary putnam download.
There is no marxist theory of meaning but there are a. Bibliography of the writings of hilary putnam compiled and edited by john r. His causal treatment of reference, developed in the mid1960s and most famously defended in the meaning of meaning 1975. By pure chance the line that it traces curves and recrosses itself in such a way that it ends up looking like a recognizable caricature of winston churchill. Even frege, who thought that meanings senses were public. This volume presents a selection of the most important writings in the debate on the nature of meaning and reference which started one hundred years ago with freges classic essay on sense and reference. His father, samuel putnam, was a wellknown author and translator. If twinoscar asks for a glass of water, and you hand him a glass of h2o and ask is this what you want, hed say yes. This was a contribution to the philosophy of language. General significance of the topic in this paper i try to contrast realist theories of meaning with what may be called idealist theories of meaning.
Hilary putnam meaning and reference hilary whitehall putnam born july 31, 1926 currently 87 years old is an american philosopher, mathematician, and computer scientist. Reason, truth and history by hilary putnam books on. Outside philosophy, putnam contributed to mathematics and computer science. Together with martin davis he developed the davisputnam. His causal treatment of reference, developed in the mid1960s and most. Hilary putnam was awarded the rolf schock prize in logic and philosophy by the royal swedish academy of sciences in 2011 for his contribution to the understanding of semantics. Unclear as it is, the traditional doctrine that the notion meaning possesses the extensionintension ambiguity has certain typical consequences. Full text of putnam, hilary reason, truth and history see other formats. Putnam s goal is to embed philosophy in social life. Putnam thinks that such terms are defined ostensively, i. To putnam, to the extent that such terms are defined ostensively, their extension actually determines their intension, in the sense that a paraphrase of the meaning of the term will be of the general form this thing right here, perhaps with an accompanying demonstration e. Putnam has two main conclusions in meaning and reference. Hilary putnam edited by yemima benmenahem january 2005.
Hilary putnam meaning and reference article summary. According to putnam why there isnt a readymade world 1983, for putnam, this picture of wordworld correspondence is absurd, pointing to a realism gone wild. Brains in a vat, subjectivity, and the causal theory of. Synthese library monographs on epistemology, logic, methodology, philosophy of science, sociology of science and of knowlegde, and on the mathematical methods of social and behavioral sciences, vol 52. Hilary putnam deals in this book with some of the most fundamental persistent problems in philosophy. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read reason, truth and history. He retains the belief that, in principle, a machine and a person can work the same way when described at the relevant. Realism with a human face hilary putnam, james conant.
The doctrine that the meaning of a term is a concept carried the implication that mean ings are mental entities. July 31, 1926 march, 2016 was an american philosopher, mathematician, and computer scientist, and a major figure in. I believe that if i am right, this will shed light on a number of things in philosophy as for example, why wittgenstein had both a picture theory of meaning and a use theory of meaning at different times, of course. Full text of putnam, hilary reason, truth and history. Bibliography of the writings of hilary putnam this bibliography lists books and then shorter writings, in chronological order. The collapse of the factvalue dichotomy and other essays. One of the most important contributions of hilary putnam s philosophy of language is the idea that the meaning is not right in the head just is not meaning in the head, an argument illustrated by the famous experiment thought the earth twin. Realism and reason hilary putnam in one way of conceiving it, realism is an empirical theory. Hilary putnam, who may have been the first philosopher to advance the notion that the computer is an apt model for the mind, takes a radically new view of his own theory of functionalism in this book. Hilary putnam meaning and reference article summary analysis. Meaning and the moral sciences hilary putnam first published in 1978, this reissue presents a seminal philosophical work by professor putnam, in which he puts forward a conception of knowledge which makes ethics, practical knowledge and nonmathematic parts of the social sciences just as much parts of knowledge as the sciences themselves.
Frege, however, rebelled against this psy chologism. Access to this document requires a subscription or membership. Putnams position is we should give up the claim that meanings are in the head. Thus, such a baptismal rite will go something like, natural kind term n means this thing in the actual world, meaning that the way the world is for putnam as much a contributor in determining reference as is any psychological state on the part of speakers, contrary to standard semantic theory.
Putnam, hilary the collapse of the fact value dichotomy and other essays hilary putnam. Putnam, hilary and ruth anna, the quarrel between poetry and philosophy, read to the santayana society at its annual meeting in new york on december 28, 1995. Knowing the meaning of a word, sentence is being in a psychological state. In what sense did putnam invent the doctrine of semantic externalism. He claims that the meaning of words are not individual mental states.
To putnam, to the extent that such terms are defined ostensively, their extension actually determines their intension, in the sense that a paraphrase of the meaning of the term will be of the general form this thing right here, perhaps with an accompanying. Meaning and reference nclear as it is, the traditional doctrine that the notion meaning possesses the extensionintension ambiguity has certain typical consequences. This is the third volume of hilary putnam s philosophical papers, published in paperback for the first time. Cogan university professor emeritus in the department of philosophy. It seems like putnam presupposes externalism when he states that oscar and twinoscar have the same mental state but different conceptual extension for water. Putnam here revises the functionalist view of mind that he formerly espoused. Putnam, hilary meaning and reference, the journal of philosophy.
1370 674 1366 681 415 1046 140 1456 1364 545 683 734 457 639 1376 917 567 1174 659 26 1430 1261 250 1267 106 799 1094 175 178 119 374 1081 1398 1119 639 240 821 163 1478 130 262 1034